thredUP Reviews | Is thredUP Legit? What You Need to Know About Sites Like thredUP

Overview: thredUP Reviews | Is thredUP Legit? What You Need to Know About Sites Like thredUP

thredUP is a consignment shop where you can sell and buy secondhand clothing, bags, and shoes online.

But is thredUP legit? Is it worth your time? In this thredUP review, we will explore several other reviews of thredUP to help you better determine if you want to shop and sell with this company or not.

There are a lot of sites likes thredUP out there, so what makes this the best possible choice for you?

The ultimate purpose of this thredUP review is to present you with all the available information necessary to make your choice as well as provide you with a thredUP promo code.

You will get both the pros and cons to buying and selling with this secondhand clothing site, with the following points being covered:

thredUP’s mission
What makes this company different from other sites like thredUP?
Buy from thredUP (pros and cons)
Sell to thredUP (pros and cons)
Conclusion of thredUP review and thredUP promo code

thredUP’s Mission

thredUP’s business model and mission consists of providing all possible customers with their choice of flaw-free, functional, and fashionable clothing.

The company boasts a rigorous screening process for its products, and it strives to only sell the highest-quality items. thredUP marks down its prices up to as much as 90% and offers various thredUP promo codes and brand-new arrivals “every minute.” It regularly sells products in the following categories:

Women
Designer
Maternity
Shoes
Handbags
Girls
Boys
Basement: flawed items discounted at a considerably lower price

Basically, resale shopping is a formidable treasure hunt, but thredUP makes the search less painful and the reward even greater.

In her thredUP review, Paula Sutter, former president of Diane Von Furstenberg and current thredUP board member, says the entire concept is to make shopping both “attractive and sustainable.”

Image source: thredUP.com

On its site, thredUP.com shares a few statistics about the benefit of resale shopping, such as, “If 1 in 100 American households shopped resale, it would save over 1.1 billion pounds of CO2 emissions every year.”

Even if you aren’t always as environmentally conscious as you should be, it’s an impressive number.

What Makes This Different from Other Sites Like thredUP?

Online consignment shopping isn’t an entirely original idea. There are many sites like thredUP out there and other choices when it comes to selling and buying secondhand clothes. You even have the option of selling at a local store as opposed to online.

However, sites like thredUP that specialize in secondhand and designer-brand clothing include the following:

Vestiaire Collective: A luxury site based out of France that specializes in vintage products. Its selling process is similar to eBay’s, and it keeps a percentage of your sale total for itself.
Rebagg: A site that sells designer bags and gives sellers their cash up front.
The Real: A site that sells both clothing and artwork; it will send a buyer to you to collect the product you wish to sell; all first-time consigners also get a $100 Saks Fifth Avenue gift card.
Walk In My Closet: This site offers sellers a choice of either direct sale, where they control their consignment, or the concierge service which allows the site to handle the whole process.
Snob Swap: This site focuses only on buying and selling luxury-brand items, like Chanel or Hermes.

Clearly, thredUP has a lot of legitimate competition when it comes to other consignment sites, and the above-mentioned sites are only just a few. However, thredUP does offer a few perks that the other sites do not.

First of all, it makes the selling process simple and pain-free. All you have to do is order a “clean out bag,” which comes with a prepaid shipping label, fill it with the clothes you’d like to sell, and ship it right back to thredUP for free. According to thredUP, you should get an offer within 2–4 weeks.

Another interesting perk of shopping and selling with thredUP is that you can either keep the money you earn from selling your clothes or donate the money to the charity of your choosing. It’s refreshing to have the option to give back to your community and to others.

Don’t Miss: Thrift Books Reviews | Objective Review of Thrift Books Online

All-in-One Change Management Tools

Top Rated Toolkit for Change Managers.

Get Your Change Management Tool Today...

Buy from thredUP (Pros and Cons)

Based on thredUP reviews and just from scanning through the merchandise online, buying clothes from this site seems like a positive experience.

The site is unique in that it stocks luxury brands like Jimmy Choo next to brands like J. Crew, Banana Republic, and Express, and it cuts prices down, sometimes up to 90% off. For all the pros of buying from thredUP, consult the following list:

Pros to Buying from thredUP

It stocks luxury brands as well as more general brands.
It has sales on top of already reduced prices.
You can send back clothes for a refund if necessary.
There is strict quality control for incoming clothes.
It has an organized and easy-to-use website.
There is a convenient thredUP app.
It is an environmentally–conscious company.
It encourages charitability in its customers.
The clothes are fashionable and up to date.
There are regular thredUP promo codes to help you save money.

Image source: thredUP.com

Typically, you would expect some negative thredUP reviews, thredUP complaints or at least a few scathing comments about the clothing. However, that’s not the case with thredUP. As far as shopping for thredUP’s clothing goes, the experience seems entirely positive. Some specific thredUP reviews include the following:

thredUP Reviews

“It’s a pretty punk-rock way to participate in the online fashion retail game, if you ask me.” – Lindsay Ginn
“thredUP is a great resource for parents of school-aged children, whatever your clothing needs might be!” – Tiffany Merrit
I think it was an easy experience and the clothes arrived within a week and a half. I have my shopping cart full with items right now, so I’d obviously buy from there again.” – Danielle

To be thorough, it’s good to mention that a valid thredUP complaint might be that it doesn’t sell any men’s clothing, making it fairly exclusive to women. Maybe it will expand its merchandise in the future.

If and when you buy from the site, make sure to note the policy for thredUP returns. You will have 14 days after receiving your order to return it if you aren’t happy. Bags and final sale items are non-returnable.

Sell to thredUP (Pros and Cons)

While buying clothes from thredUP appears to be a mostly, if not completely, positive experience, the thredUP reviews for selling to it are more ambiguous. There are conflicting opinions, including both thredUP complaints and praise. First of all, consult the following pros:

Pros of Selling to thredUP

It makes it easy for you (order its “clean out” bag, fill it, and send it back).
The “clean out” bag is free to ship.
You can choose to receive cash or website credit.
You have the option to donate to the charity of your choice.

Image source: thredUP.com

Cons of Selling to thredUP

There is a lot of selling traffic, so getting an offer can take a long time.
It is notoriously picky about what clothes it accepts (this is a pro for buying clothes from the site).
It doesn’t pay its sellers very well for their clothes.

For more specific customer thredUP reviews, see the following comments and thredUP complaints about selling clothes to them:

“I do not recommend thredUP to anyone! It took them nearly 3 months to work out that my bag and clothes will be out of season by then. I had brand new items in my bag that were new with price tags attached.” – Montanagal1
“Do not use this terrible company. Long story short, I sent in my bags of clothes and I received back $10.95 and an email with the 4 items they will be using. Those items are reselling for a total of $72.96. Out of that, let me remind you, they gave me $10.95. Worst suggestion to use this company. – Drea620
“They sold my items for $90.41 and gave me $7.00. Visit a local consignment store instead of using this company. You will be helping a local business and get more cash for your items.” – Connie_snyder07
“I was excited to sell on this site and carefully selected high quality items that I knew would sell, including a pair of brand new Miraclebody jean capris, size 10, that sell for $92. You know what they sold them for? $19.99. I got a whopping $2. – Eucher2
“I was so disappointed with my experience selling to thredUP. I sent them a bag with over 20 items, including a brand new Lularoe skirt, and received a whopping 0.90 for two items.” – Caitlin D.

Ultimately, thredUP reviews seem significantly less thrilled with the selling process than with the buying process. The thredUP reviews of the later are mostly negative, full of thredUP complaints and people expressing their frustration with the company as well as the amount of money they received in return for their clothes, bags, and shoes.

Conclusion of thredUP Review and thredUP Promo Code

All things considered, thredUP appears to be a valid option if you’re looking into online consignment shopping.

Its products are attractive, fashionable, current, and well-priced, and the site is continually updated. Plus, as an added bonus for shoppers, it seems to be concerned for the environment and its effect on it as well as for local communities and charity.

The company wants to do its small part to help the world and gives its customers the chance to do the same. The following are some general praise and thredUP complaints based on thredUP reviews.

thredUP Praise

It sells good quality products.
It sets a low price for its clothes, bags, and shoes.
Its mission is respectable.
The buying and selling process is an easy one.

thredUP Complaints

It doesn’t have men’s fashion available to buy.
It doesn’t pay its sellers well.

Overall, thredUP seems like a spectacular choice, and the thredUP reviews are highly subjective. The negative thredUP reviews and thredUP complaints about low-sale returns are to be expected with a site like this, and people may sometimes be easily offended when it comes to selling their own clothes.

If you are someone who is looking to sell your unwanted clothes with ease and make a little money at the same time, thredUP is probably a good place to start. If you want to shop for cheap, cute clothes, thredUP is a good place for that too.

AdvisoryHQ (AHQ) Disclaimer:

Reasonable efforts have been made by AdvisoryHQ to present accurate information, however all info is presented without warranty. Review AdvisoryHQ’s Terms for details. Also review each firm’s site for the most updated data, rates and info.

Note: Firms and products, including the one(s) reviewed above, may be AdvisoryHQ's affiliates. Click to view AdvisoryHQ's advertiser disclosures.